Home

Traumatic Experiences in Correctional Facilities:   Who Has it Worse?  Correctional Staff or Those who are Incarcerated

By Jillian ShaneJune 20th, 2021in CJ 720

Traumatic Experiences in Correctional Facilities:   Who Has it Worse?  Correctional Staff or Those who are Incarcerated

When thinking of what it would be like to be incarcerated, the lay person can base their perception on any number of popular televisions shows or movies; abusive staff, gangs, stabbings, rapes and a pervasive culture of violence.  While these things do occur, in some facilities much more than others, many short term, low custody sentences may not experience these things firsthand.  However, the constant fear of the above referenced items coupled with poor (if not disgusting) food quality, strip searches, group showers, unsanitary conditions, lack of access to family/friends, lack of sleep due to keys, doors, and cell checks, and reduced/delayed access to medical and mental health may in fact lead to greater negative emotions and trauma.  Any piece or combination thereof can lead to PTSD upon release back into society.  In addition, “Other factors are interwoven into the pathogenesis of this condition, including the many risk factors that underlie the behavioral and thought patterns of many criminals. These include childhood traumas such as extreme poverty, child abuse by their parents or caregivers, experiences of neglect, physical and sexual abuse, as well as other forms of mistreatment” (Thomas, 2019).

According to various research projects:

  • Even before entering a prison or jail, incarcerated people are more likely than those on the outside to have experiencedabuse and trauma (Thomas, L, 2019).
  • An extensive 2014 studyfound that 30% to 60% of men in state prisons had post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), compared to 3% to 6% of the general male population (Wolff, N, et al, 2014).
  • 7% of womenin state prisons experienced childhood abuse, compared to 12 to 17% of all adult women in the U.S.. (BJA, 1999).

The below chart is from the Prison Policy Initiative article titled No escape: The trauma of witnessing violence in Prison:

Estimating the prevalence of violence in prisons and jails
Reported incidents and estimates
Indicator of violence State prisons Federal prisons County jails Source
Deaths by suicide in correctional facility 255 deaths in 2016 333 deaths in 2016 Mortality in State and Federal Prisons, 2001-2016Mortality in Local Jails, 2000-2016
Deaths by homicide in correctional facility 95 deaths in 2016 31 deaths in 2016
“Intentionally injured” by staff or other incarcerated person since admission to prison 14.8% of incarcerated people in 2004 8.3% of incarcerated people in 2004 Survey of Inmates in State and Federal Correctional Facilities, 2004
“Staff-on-inmate assaults” 21% of incarcerated men were assaulted by staff over 6 months in 2005 Wolff & Shi, 2010
“Inmate-on-inmate assaults” 26,396 assaults in 2005 Census of State and Federal Adult Correctional Facilities, 2005
Incidents of sexual victimization of incarcerated people (perpetrated by staff and incarcerated people) 16,940 reported incidents in 2015 740 reported incidents in 2015 5,809 reported incidents in 2015 Survey of Sexual Victimization, 2015
1,473 substantiated incidents in state and federal prisons and local jails in 2015

 

The above charts and studies, however, only examined the effects of correctional environments on those who were incarcerated inside by judicial order and did not consider those who work inside the facilities, often for long and mandated shifts.  Not as many studies could be found on correctional staff related trauma.  But trauma and stress amongst staff can easily be imagined: reviewing horrific case files; witnessing traumatic events; mandatory overtime; role ambiguity; and constant disrespect by the inmate population.  “According to a 2015 article by the National Commission on Correctional Health Care, correctional employees experience higher rates of stress-related illnesses that contribute to low levels of job satisfaction, which has been linked to burnout and is thought to lead to compassion fatigue” (Pittaro, M., 2020). 

In addition, a study conducted and published this year found that correctional officers self-reported significantly higher exposure to potentially psychologically traumatic events than other medical and wellness workers. Moreover, correctional staff also self-reported greater rates of symptoms of mental disorders, including PTSD, social anxiety, panic disorder, and depression, among others (Fusco, N., et al, 2021). 

Based on the above referenced data and numerous additional uncited studies, it is evident from the research and probably obvious to the average law abiding civilian, that both correctional staff and inmates are exposed to the unimaginable and unfathomable behind the walls.  Typically, opposing sides prevent the evolution and availability of growth for each of these populations:  those who may believe that inmates deserve this and should not be afforded anything when being punished and those that may feel that correctional staff are tough and know what they sign up for.  Acknowledging the equality in the two groups and making available trauma informed approaches to care for the inmate populations and programming for self-care for staff is critical to reduce these numbers and ensure smooth transitions for each in society.  The truth is, that nearly all inmates will one day be released into society and, in addition, will be existing with us.  Moreover, staff as well are living amongst us, on their often-limited time off, and should as well be able to ‘leave it at the gate’ in terms of their work stressors.  To that note, similarly, one a sentence and work shift is complete, any individual should be, and we should want them to be, functioning, healthy and productive members of the society in which we all live. 

 

References:

Bureau of Justice Assistance (BJA).  1999.  Prior Abuse Reported by Inmates and Probationers. https://bjs.ojp.gov/content/pub/pdf/parip.pdf. 

Fusco, N., Ricciardello, Jamshidi, Carleton, Barnim and Hilton.  (February 15, 2021).  When Our Work Hits Home: Trauma and Mental Disorders in Correctional Officers and Other Correctional Workers.  National Institutes of Health.  https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7917131/. 

Pittaro, Michael.  March 24, 2020).  Correctional Officers and Compassion Fatigue.  Psychology Today.  https://www.psychologytoday.com/au/blog/the-crime-and-justice-doctor/202003/correctional-officers-and-compassion-fatigue. 

Thomas, Dr. Liji.  (February 27, 2019).  Prisoner Post Traumatic Stress.  Medical Life Sciences News.  https://www.news-medical.net/health/Prisoner-Post-Traumatic-Stress.aspx.   

Widra, Emily. (December 2, 2020).  No escape: The trauma of witnessing violence in Prison.  Prison Policy Initiative.  https://www.prisonpolicy.org/blog/2020/12/02/witnessing-prison-violence/#lf-fnref:1. 

Trauma Informed Policing by Frederick Morse

By femorseJune 19th, 2021in CJ 720

In recent years perhaps no profession has received as much scrutiny as law enforcement. Americans are redefining social norms and expecting more professionalism and accountability from law enforcement. One of the areas in law enforcement that has been beneficial, yet not without growing pains, has been the proliferation of body-worn video cameras. An additional facet of American life that has also received a fair amount of attention is trauma and mental illness. Research has shown that early childhood trauma can result in hindered growth resulting in uncontrolled anger, inappropriate behavior, disregard for rules, and drug or alcohol abuse (Rousseau, 2021). These precursors often result in contacts with law enforcement.

In the United States, a growing number of service requests for law enforcement similarly involve police interaction with vulnerable individuals or those experiencing a psychologically based crisis.   A recent study in Scotland revealed that approximately 80% of all calls for service for law enforcement were non-criminal in nature (Gillespie-Smith, 2020).

With this dynamic in mind, scholars in Scotland conducted research where they exposed police personnel to trauma informed practices. Specifically, the study chose one police division and showed them the documentary “Resilience: The Body of Stress and Science of Hope.” The documentary explained how chronic stress releases hormones within the body of children which then results in dysfunction in the minds and bodies of youth. After viewing the film, the police personnel were given an overview of the 1998 Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACE) study and scores. There was a panel of experts available for questions and to provide further context for the data.

Police personnel learned that in Wales, individuals with an ACE score of four or more were twenty times more likely to be incarcerated at some point in their life than the general public (Bellis, 2015).  Similarly, the officers learned that approximately 89% of the prisoners in Wales reported at least one ACE (Gillespie-Smith, 2020). Police personnel who received the trauma informed training were then questioned as to their attitudes and understanding about suspects, witnesses, and victims. The researchers then compared the answers with answers from officers from another police division that did not receive the trauma informed policing training. The answers were not significantly different (Gillespie-Smith, 2020). Many of the officers who received the training expressed confusion about the ACE score research. The officers indicated that the trauma had occurred before their involvement and they failed to see how the new knowledge could benefit their current role. This was a common theme in the feedback from the participants (Gillespie-Smith, 2020).

On its face, the scholarly work in Scotland appeared to be unremarkable. However, if law enforcement agencies in the United States could build upon this trauma informed approach to policing and combine it with the technology of body worn video, real progress could be made. Law enforcement personnel have countless contacts and calls for service with individuals with mental health needs. A trauma informed approach to these calls for service could curtail any use of force and would result in decreasing further trauma to the individual in crisis or the officer.

Law enforcement administrators need to seek out strategies for improved professionalism and techniques for de-escalation. With the use of body worn video, contacts with individuals in crisis or mental health decompensation can be reviewed by law enforcement trainers and mental health professionals to improve officer responses and protocols. All contacts with citizens with mental health needs would be given a unique computerized clearance code making it easier to identify and retrieve the incidents for later review. The review of body worn video would be for educational purposes only, with the goal of improving trauma informed practices for law enforcement personnel. Police agencies could generate training videos from body worn video footage from actual interactions. The videos would include instructional narratives from mental health professionals and would be disseminated to other stations and personnel.  A secondary objective would be to ensure that law enforcement personnel are getting the necessary and timely assistance from mental health agencies. If both agencies can work in a collaborative manner, individuals in crisis might receive professional intervention and proper care instead of a trip to the county jail.

Submitted by: Frederick Morse

 

Works Cited

Bellis, M. A. (2015). Adverse Childhood Experiences and their Impact on Health-Harming Behaviours in the Welsh Population. Wales: Cardiff: Public Health.

Gillespie-smith, K. B. (2020, August). Moving Towards Trauma-Informed Policing: An Exploration of Police Officer's Attitudes and Perceptions Toward Adverse Childhood Experinces (ACEs). Retrieved from https://www.research.ed.ac.uk/en/publications/moving-towards-trauma-informed-policing-an-exploration-of-police-#:~:text=In%202018%20Ayrshire%20Division%20of%20Police%20Scotland%20announced,perceptions%20and%20attitudes%20towards%20becoming%20a%20trauma-in

Rousseau, D. (2021). Trauma and Crisis Intervention. Module 2 Study Guide. Boston University.

Is Art Therapy a Legitimate Form of Treatment?

By Dominic ManganoJune 19th, 2021

According to the American Art Therapy Association, art therapy can be defined as a mental health and human service aimed at engaging the mind, body, and spirit through visual and symbolic expression. The goal of this therapy is to empower individuals, communities, and society by giving a voice to experience through this visual/symbolic expression. It is used to, "increase cognitive and sensorimotor functions, foster self-esteem and self-awareness, cultivate emotional resilience, promote insight, enhance social skills, reduce and resolve conflicts and distress, and advance societal and ecological change." Art therapy is administered through master-level clinicians at schools, prisons, hospitals, psychiatric and rehabilitation facilities, senior centers, etc. to treat people with medical and mental health problems, and those in search of emotional, creative, or spiritual growth (American Art Therapy Association , 2017).

It may just be me, but I feel like compared to other mental health practitioners, Art Therapists may be looked down on. When you hear the term "Art Therapist",  you may think that the job is a walk in the park or just a chaperone coloring with kids. That could not be further from the truth. Art Therapist's go through an extensive amount of schooling and training in order to give the patients the quality and therapeutic care that they need. To become an Art Therapist, a master's degree is needed for ENTRY LEVEL in the field with coursework including: training in the creative process, psychological development, group therapy, art therapy assessment, psychodiagnostics, research methods, and multicultural diversity competence. Upon completion of graduate school, the future therapist must become board certified through the Art Therapy Credentials Board. To accompany that, therapists must complete 100 hours of supervised work along with 600 hours of a clinical internship. I know what you are all thinking and no, the Art Therapy Association does not consider an adult coloring book a form of therapy because it is not administered by a licensed Art Therapist (American Art Therapy Association , 2017). With that being said, they do not discourage the use of one. Would you trust an Art Therapist for you or a loved ones counseling needs? 

Below I have attached a video of Donna Betts, PhD, ATR-BC explaining how art therapy is administered to people with Autism Spectrum Disorder:

When it comes to clinical effectiveness of art therapy in all sorts of patients, multiple studies have been done and yield interesting results. When it comes to those with depression, in nine studies it was found that art therapy significantly reduced depression in six of those cases. In seven studies examining anxiety, six of those studies showed a strong decrease in anxiety. In the three studies addressing trauma, all of them showed a reduction of trauma symptoms. In the one study examining cognition, the control group showed significant improvements in cognitive function relative to the art therapy group. Finally, when it comes to distress, the three groups all were found to show a reduced amount of distress (Uttley, 2015). There is a lot of research out there proving the benefits of art therapy in all sorts of realms. With this being the case you would think that art therapy would be offered as a practice more than it is.  Even though personally I am not a very talented artist, I feel as if looking at art and its beauty is an instant mood elevator. Regardless of your artistic ability, would you be interested in trying art therapy?

 

Art work done by sexual abuse survivor "Maxine" when asked to draw how she feels emotionally on a daily basis (The Palmeira Practice, 2018).

 

 

References:

About Art Therapy. American Art Therapy Association. (2017). https://arttherapy.org/about-art-therapy/

Art Therapy in Action. American Art Therapy Association. (2017). https://arttherapy.org/art-therapy-action/

The Palmeira Practice | Brighton & Hove Counselling. (2018, February 23). Working with sexual abuse in art therapy - The Palmeira Practice: Brighton & Hove Counselling. The Palmeira Practice | Brighton & Hove Counselling. https://www.thepalmeirapractice.org.uk/expertise/2018/2/22/working-with-sexual-abuse-in-art-therapy.

Uttley, L. (2015, March). Clinical effectiveness of art therapy: quantitative systematic review. Systematic review and economic modelling of the clinical effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of art therapy among people with non-psychotic mental health disorders.

 

Liquid Trauma Treatment and Law Enforcement

By cdiloJune 19th, 2021in CJ 720

For most professionals, when colleagues ask to grab a few drinks after work, this is seen as a friendly gesture to build relationships at the workplace. For law enforcement this can be seen and used as a way to cope with the stress and trauma from the job or to self medicate for anxiety, depression or post-traumatic stress disorder. While the exact number is hard to calculate, it is estimated that approximately 23% of all police officers in the United States are alcoholics. To put that into perspective, there are an estimated 800,000 sworn officers in the United States which would mean approximately 184,000 officers are considered alcoholics. Some officer’s may have already been or will eventually become alcoholics, prior to being hired, due to genetic predisposition or the environment they were raised in. While this may be true, it is easy to see how the job and the lack of mental health resources available would lead to such troubling statistics. 

The day I was hired and sworn in as a police officer, a family friend, who was an active duty police officer at the time, told me that I now had “a front row seat to the greatest show on earth.” Without knowing what the job entailed and the mental health issues that face police officers, I find it somewhat ironic that my family friend and I were drinking at the time. I saw the occasion as a celebration while he may have seen it as a way to self medicate to ease the pain of  the demons he carried with him as a result of being a cop. The idea that I could sign up for a job where every day, every hour, and every minute was different sounded too good to be true. And at first, this was exactly what it was like for me every time I pulled that bullet proof vest over my head, buttoned up my uniform shirt, and shined my boots. Today, every time I put on that vest, I am quickly overcome with stress and anxiety of the unknown. The adventures of the job and the adrenaline filled incidents that I yearned for quickly became mundane and I felt as if I was becoming complacent which is a killer in this job. “The very nature of police work includes regular and ongoing exposure to confrontation, violence, and potential harm. Exposure to potentially traumatic experiences on a regular basis sets the stage for a series of mental health complications, including posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD)” (Maguen et al., 2009, p. 754).

Perhaps it was because of the COVID lockdowns without much else to do, or perhaps it was me subconsciously self medicating from the stress of the job, but I soon found myself drinking almost every night. My fiancé recognized this and quickly made me realize that it was becoming a problem. I am extremely fortunate and grateful that my fiancé had the courage to speak up and confront me about my drinking habits. For many this resource is not available and they are left searching for help while fighting to stay anonymous. The search may continue long enough where officers feel they don't have any options and end up take their own lives. “Law enforcement suicide is real and is the number one killer of police officers,” occurring “1.5 times more frequently than suicide in the general population” (Rousseau, 2021, p. 7).

The stigma around mental health and its subsequent treatment is extremely prevalent in law enforcement but the more alarming issue is the lack of resources available to officers. This may be because of the stigma but leaders within the profession have a moral and ethical obligation to do better. I have heard from some classmates that their departments offer mandatory mental health services without questions asked and their colleagues are far better for it. This is an example of forward thinking leadership while combating the stigma that surrounds mental health. The country needs more leaders like this to step up and take care of their own. This will not only lead to healthier officers but it will also lead to better relationships with the public they serve. 

Bibliography:

“How Common Is Alcoholism with Police Officers? - The Recovery Village.” The Recovery Village Drug and Alcohol Rehab, The Recovery Village Drug and Alcohol Rehab, 22 Dec. 2020, www.therecoveryvillage.com/alcohol-abuse/related-topics/facts-alcoholism-police-officers/. 

Maguen, S., Metzler, T. J., McCaslin, S. E., Inslicht, S. S., Henn-Haase, C., Neylan, T. C., & Marmar, C. R. (2009). Routine Work Environment Stress and PTSD Symptoms in Police Officers. Journal of Nervous & Mental Disease, 197(10), 754–760. https://doi.org/10.1097/nmd.0b013e3181b975f8

Rousseau, D. (2021). Module 6 Study Guide [Notes]. Boston University Metropolitan College.

Self-Care and Trauma

By mawelshJune 15th, 2021in CJ 720

People who experience trauma deserve to be free from the weight and pain that it bears upon them. Throughout this class, we have discussed multiple treatment methods that can work individually or that can be used together to find the best treatment plan for the individual. Not all treatments are as widely accepted as others and one that seems to walk on that fine line is self-care. Self-care however is an important part of healing from the trauma, but it should be started when the individual is ready for that experience. Trauma affects our entire body, mind, and our whole being. When all of these aspects are affected we have a harder time being present, connecting, and relating to others. By focusing on ourselves through self-care, our mind and body can work together again to create a healthy and happy lifestyle that may have not existed before. 

Highland Springs Clinic mentions that on one’s journey to healing and recovering from a traumatic event, it is important to remember the practice of self-care. They also wrote that “self-care is not commonly the first method survivors think of when they are overcoming a traumatic experience, however, it is a critical part of healing”(Hood,2020). Before starting any kind of trauma therapy, it is important to understand what trauma is and how it may present itself in you. Knowing when to start self-care is dependent on the individual and they have to allow themselves to be ready. Self-care is not the same for everyone, but listening to your body and mind and what it needs is a first step for starting this journey. Our body usually recognizes what we need and will signal to us when the time for recovery is here. Highland Springs Clinic mentions some areas of self-care that are good to start with are get more rest, find someone to talk to, journal about it, use exercise as a tool, and find engaging hobbies (Hood, 2020). While this is only a shortlist of self-care options they are good places to start for people who are ready to treat their trauma by loving themselves. 

Whitney Goodman LMFT, a licensed psychotherapist brings up a good point that self-care is supposed to make us better in the long-term and that it is not a quick fix. In society now, the term “self-care is officially a commodity, and people are buying it off the shelves to prove that they care about themselves”(Goodman, 2019). It is important that people who chose self-care to help them with their trauma understand that learning to love yourself and take time for yourself is not an easy process. Goodman stated “real self-care happens in the decisions you make every day and it requires practice, commitment and putting yourself first and getting in touch with what you really need, not just what you really want”(Goodman, 2019). Her short list of self-care is: get in touch with your feelings and actual needs, practice kindness, and ask yourself “what do I need at this moment”. One big point that Goodman and Highland Springs Clinics mentioned is staying away from drinking or using substances since it is not self-care. There are so many different kinds of self-care out there, that experimenting with them will help us find which ones work for us. It is important that people who have experienced trauma believe that they deserve self-care before starting to practice it. 

Everyone that goes through a traumatic experience reacts differently emotionally, psychologically, and physically. Being able to accept and be ready for the step of self-care is important to accept the responsibility for yourself, your body, and your mind. Finding a positive self-care routine when ready to embark on the journey will help the overall healing process. It is important to remember that there is no right or wrong way to self-care, it is all about what helps that individual after trauma to become whole again. Dr. Bessel Van Der Kolk writes “the full story can be told only after those structures are repaired and after the groundwork has been laid: after no body becomes some body”(Van Der Kolk, 2015, p.249). Trauma is stressful, but acting on self-care can alleviate that stress. As well as realizing that the trauma needs to be dealt with in a positive way and wanting to deal with it will help accomplish the first step with the journey of self-care.

 

References

Goodman, W. (2019, July 12). When Self-Care Becomes a Weapon. Psychology Today. https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/healing-together/201907/when-self-care-becomes-weapon. 

Ph.D., D. Julia. Hood. (2020, January 27). The Importance of Self-Care After Trauma. Highland Springs. https://highlandspringsclinic.org/blog/the-importance-of-self-care-after-trauma/. 

Ocrcc. (2020, October 12). self-care Archives. OCRCC. https://ocrcc.org/tag/self-care/.

Van Der Kolk, B. (2015). The Body keeps the score brain, mind, and body in the healing of trauma. Penguin Books.

 

Complicity is dependent on what from the ordinary people?

By ptmcaoJune 15th, 2021

Even with the magnitude of the Holocaust serving as a reminder of humanity’s complicity to sadistic values, genocide continues to be an enduring issue that challenges our core beliefs of right and wrong. The Bosnian genocide, the East Timor genocide, and the Darfur genocide—these are some of the mass killings committed after the Holocaust, and despite those lessons learned from the atrocities in Auschwitz, genocide is a nationwide concern that has motivated many scholars and researchers to understand the social context of such behaviors in hopes of fore-fronting changes.

According to Dr. Rousseau, genocide is dependent on the complicity of ordinary people, but to what extent (2021)? While complicity emphasizes the involvement with others in an activity considered as wrong, how subjective is this threshold when measuring someone’s contribution? Though the parameters can vary from active engagement to the bystander effect, both ends of the spectrum ascertains that free will has a strong influence on complicity and its connection to moral judgment in a genocide context (Adelman, 2003).

In the Stanford Prison Experiment (SPE), scholar Philip Zimbardo exploited a controlled observational experiment to examine the focus of social influences and perception through the psychological effects of power and conformity between the prisoners and the prison guards (1971). Conveyed as the main highlight, upon provided a new fictitious identity, both prisoners and guards disengaged their moral values and immediately embraced their new characters, accepting the psychological abuse and power without hesitation (Alvarez, 2015). Reiterated by Elie Wiesel’s autobiographical account, Night, concepts of “right” and “wrong” disappear the moment the first transport arrived in Auschwitz (2006). Does the setting have any influences over the nature of cognitive awareness on moral values? According to Zimbardo’s findings, the study highlighted the observed behaviors from the undergraduate students as a situational occurrence—reinforcing that it is not always of a dispositional attribute or innate behavior (McLeod, 2012).

Additionally, in the Milgram Experiment, scholar Stanley Milgram extended Zimbardo’s situational finding by studying obedience to authority. In its entirety, if placed in the right situation, people will comply to authoritative directives even when it challenges their moral values (Syzdykova, 2014). While the study highlights a selective characteristic that qualifies responsibility as the determining factor for such involvement, the study really sheds light on the conflict between obedience to authority and personal conscience. In its face-value, obedience to authority takes on Zimbardo’s analysis of situational attribution, meanwhile, the path to decisions falls on the phenomenon of free will—the ability of oneself to cognitively decide. As a result, which theory best answers one’s complicity to behaviors like genocide—situational or dispositional?

While the Reserve Battalion 101, a paramilitary formation during the Holocaust responsible for the expulsion of Poles to the mass shootings of Jews, operated on a mechanistic view of moral judgment that describes both situational and dispositional patterns, how does our understanding of the SPE and the Milgram Experiment describe which attribute best explains the threshold of complicity to genocide? According to Browning, Zimbardo’s study was more relevant to the Reserve Battalion 101 given many of the men in the battalion were ordinary people, with no criminal records or history of murderous and heinous beliefs (1992). Similarly to the undergraduate students, the results shed light on their ability to selectively engage and disengage moral standards (Alvarez, 2015). The selectively engagement and disengagement is seen through their hesitation. Characterized by Browning, “while the men of Reserve Police Battalion 101 were willing to shoot Jews too weak or sick to move, they still shied for the most part from shooting infants, despite their orders” (1992). This behavior of feeling “shied” is the inner moral workings and conflicts of obedience to authority, willingness to participate, and deferment in responsibilities.

Although some may argue the environment offers a situational attribute that persuades one to behave in a certain manner, these decisions to engage or to disengage are part of a constant rationalization that occurs in a person’s free will. Doing the right thing versus becoming self-preserved in order to avoid the apathy of fear and embarrassment—these are some of the thought processes that are passively being sourced through a cost-benefit analysis to determine which action is more suitable for the person, in the specific environment. As a result, despite situational factors, dispositional best supports that genocide is dependent on the complicity of the individual, arguing that everyone passively engages in rationalizing for their own benefit.

 

References

Adelman, H. (2003). Review: Bystanders to genocide in Rwanda. The International History Review. Taylor & Francis, Ltd. https://www.jstor.org/stable/40109323

Alvarez, K. P. (2015). The Stanford prison experiment. IFC Films.

Browning, C. R. (1992). Ordinary men: Reserve police battalion 101 and the final solution in Poland. HarperCollins.

McLeod, S. (2012). Attribution theory. Simply Psychology. https://www.simplypsychology.org/attribution-theory.html

Rousseau, D. (2021). Module 5: Trauma, Genocide, and the Holocaust. Boston University Metropolitan College: Blackboard.

Syzdykova, K. (2014). The Milgram experiment. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=760lwYmpXbc

Zimbardo, P. (1971). The Stanford prison experiment: A simulation study of the psychology of imprisonment conducted August 1971 at Stanford university. Stanford University. https://web.stanford.edu/dept/spec_coll/uarch/exhibits/Narration.pdf

Acupuncture as Trauma Therapy

By Danielle CavaliereJune 12th, 2021in CJ 720

Over the relatively short period of time that trauma treatment has been studied, there has been a myriad of different methods proven to help trauma victims in one way or another. Despite this, there is yet to be a cure-all that works completely for every individual and every trauma. To fully accept the reality of a trauma and be free from the weight it bears, multiple treatment methods working in tandem with one another is the best approach for healing.

One treatment method that is less often discussed but proven effective is acupuncture. Acupuncture is an ancient Chinese practice that utilizes small needles placed along pressure points on the body to help with energy flow and pain relief. Chinese documents dating as far back as 100 BCE describe the system of diagnosis and treatment that is now recognized as acupuncture (White & Ernst, 2004). The original idea of flowing meridians in the body has given way to modern neurology’s explanation that the needles stimulate nerve endings and brain function (White & Ernst, 2004). While the practice is centuries old and has been utilized in cultures across the globe, there is surprisingly little research on its effects.

Although there is little research on the subject, other forms of therapies have developed from its principles. Emotional Freedom Techniques is a more common method that, while self-administered, relies on the same bodily energy flows as acupuncture and has also been proven to cure the physical and psychological effects of trauma. In a survey following the September 11th attacks, the 225 individuals questioned said that acupuncture was the most effective method in helping them overcome the immediate trauma of being in the Towers (Van der Kolk, 2014). Acupuncture has also been found to be a “promising treatment option for anxiety, sleep disturbances, depression and chronic pain” as related to the trauma spectrum responses (Lee et al., 2012). While more research is needed to identify the mechanism of action between the needles and the actual relief, the success stories speak for themselves and make the practice a worthy contender for comorbid treatment.

The way acupuncture can aid in trauma recovery is by alleviating the symptoms either directly or residually caused by the event. For example, after a car accident, an individual might suffer pain in their neck and experience anxiety whenever they are in a car again. Acupuncture can help to relieve the neck pain that both hinders quality of life and acts as a constant reminder of the accident. Chronic pain is also a common side effect of adverse childhood experiences. When an adult comes in for therapy with a long history of repeat traumas, alleviating physical pain is a great starting point to begin recovery. This allows for a greater sense of control in one’s own body and opens doors for further therapeutic practices like yoga and exercise that would not have been possible with chronic pain. Acupuncture may not be the cure-all that therapists and researchers are looking for to help their patients overcome past traumas but its longstanding history and overwhelming success rate for non-trauma related pain demands more research be conducted on the practice’s effects on trauma.

 

References:

Lee, C., Crawford, C., Wallerstedt, D., York, A., Duncan, A., Smith, J., Sprengel, M., Welton, R., & Jonas, W. (2012). The Effectiveness of Acupuncture Research Across Components of the Trauma Spectrum Response (TSR): A Systematic Review of Reviews. Systematic Reviews, 1(1). https://doi.org/10.1186/2046-4053-1-46

Van der Kolk, B. A. (2014). The Body Keeps the Score. [VitalSource Bookshelf]. Retrieved from https://bookshelf.vitalsource.com/#/books/9781101608302/

White, A., & Ernst, E. (2004). A Brief History of Acupuncture. Rheumatology, 662–663. https://doi.org/10.1093/rheumatology/keg005.

 

 

Internet and Sexual Offenders

By bannetteMay 3rd, 2021in CJ 725

Back in model five it was discussed that technology has increased the numbers of sexually based crimes. Producers of child pornography is statically more likely to be someone the child knows, who has complete and legitimate access to the child. Technology has also led to more sexual grooming. Research into online sexual grooming has largely been focused on the stages of grooming, typologies of offenders, or comparisons with people who download abusive sexual images of children. Extraordinarily little attention has been paid to internet affordance and the role these might play in the offending behavior, the development of expertise, and the avoidance of detection. There was a qualitative study done on 14 convicted men, those convicted of online grooming. Analysis indicated that the internet served to create a private space to engage in purposive, sexual behavior with young people. The internet aided in the fantasy, and for some was precursor to an offline sexual assault. Grooming is the process by which an individual prepares a child and their environment of sexual abuse to take place, including gaining access to the child, creating compliance and trust, and ensuring secrecy to avoid detection. (Craven, Brown, and Gilchrist, 2006). Sexual grooming pre-dates the internet, Lanning (2001) described grooming activities in relation to the internet, individuals attempted to sexually exploit children by seducing their targets with attention, affection, kindness, and gifts. Between 2000 and 2006 showed a 21 percent increase in online predators.

Are online sexual offenders different than other sexual offenders? There are studies how argued that online sexual offending is simply what happens when conventional sexual offenders have access child pornography through mail-order services or through personal trades now access large volumes of child pornography online. Similarly, those who might have approached children in public such as malls, are now contacting children through social network sites, messaging, and other technologies. However, there is a counter study that states that the internet has created a different type of sexual offender. Specifically, the anonymity of the internet, accessibility of child pornography; and greater opportunities to trade child porn, contact potential victims, and engage in conspiracies to commit sexual offenses have facilitated illegal sexual behavior.

 

Quayle, Ethel, Allegro, Silvia, Hutton, Linda, Sheath, Michael, & Lööf, Lars. (2014). Rapid skill acquisition and online sexual grooming of children. Computers in Human Behavior, 39, 368–375. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chb.2014.07.005

Seto, Michael C, & Karl Hanson, R. (2011). Introduction to Special Issue on Internet-Facilitated Sexual Offending. Sexual Abuse, 23(1), 3–6. https://doi.org/10.1177/1079063211399295

 

Immigration, the far Right and Terrorism

By jy93April 30th, 2021

 

Marginalized groups are particularly vulnerable to stress and mental illness, especially ethnic minorities. Such problems are most pronounced among second-generation immigrants [1]. Children from immigrant families have a higher risk of schizophrenia and stress trauma compared to the majority ethnic group [2]. According to Racism and mental, Discrimination affects early psychological development. Exposure to everyday discrimination in childhood may lead to trauma and stress in adulthood, as well as other physical problems (U. Kluge, 2020) [3].

 

In many sociological studies of immigrant populations, a lot of social exclusion can be found. Immigrants often have tighter social networks in their immigrant communities. Compare with mainstream society, their networks tend to be much smaller [4]. Those social exclusion and isolation increases the risk of mental illness [2]. In 2019, the EU-27 unemployment rate for people aged 20 to 64 years was 12.3 % for those born outside the EU, 7.3 % for those born in another EU Member State and 6.0 % for the native-born population [7]. There is no data on the impact of mental health problems on employment, but academic failure resulting from an unhealthy upbringing may have an impact on employability later in life.

 

This isolation and closure has some relevance to terrorist activities. In some cases, although there was no evidence that the perpetrators of terrorist acts had mental problems, the impact of culturally gated communities on them was visible. In addition, disgust, hatred and contempt for the mainstream society are the most common attitudes. For example, in the 7 July 2005 London bombings, 52 people were killed and more than 700 injured. The four suicide bombers, were all from immigrant families, made a video statement before carrying out the attack:

“I and thousands like me are forsaking everything for what we believe. Our drive and motivation doesn't come from tangible commodities that this world has to offer. Our religion is Islam, obedience to the one true God and following the footsteps of the final prophet messenger. Your democratically-elected governments continuously perpetuate atrocities against my people all over the world. And your support of them makes you directly responsible, just as I am directly responsible for protecting and avenging my Muslim brothers and sisters. Until we feel security you will be our targets and until you stop the bombing, gassing, imprisonment and torture of my people we will not stop this fight. We are at war and I am a soldier. Now you too will taste the reality of this situation”[5].

 

Although the proportion of people with immigrant backgrounds exposed to extreme religious ideas is low, the damage of reputation of the immigrant community can be enormous. In the last two decades, a number of terrorist attacks based on extremist religious ideology have occurred. For example, on August 17, 2017, the extremist group Islamic State claimed responsibility for the attack that a van plowed into pedestrians in the center of Barcelona, killing at least 13 people and injuring more than 50; November 2015 Paris attacks, “Jihadists” killed 130 people, another 416 people were injured. Records show that the perpetrators of these terrorist attacks came from immigrant families.

 

Immigrant communities, surrounded by their kinsfolk, retain a strong sense of identity with their homeland. For terrorists, the mass base is better in immigrant communities, where discontent with the state is high and concentrated in communities where the administrative force is weak (the police are afraid to go or do not want to manage).The culture of these communities is predominantly anti-government, anti-police, proud to throw rocks at police cars, ashamed to report informants, facilitating terrorist movement, propaganda, logistics, and development referrals. The Algerian community is one of the most common immigrant communities in France. Algerian War of Independence (1954-1962), resulting in a large number of Algerian deaths. The French eventually abandoned Algeria, leaving the locals with bad memories of mass killings and torture. But after Algeria gained independence in 1962, this French-hating country became France's biggest source of immigrants. Although the policy of France is against various ethnic groups living together to form communities, it has accumulated difficulties over the decades and formed a large number of so-called sensitive areas with high incidence of public security incidents.

Algerians are the largest immigrant community in France, accounting for 12.8 percent of the total number of foreigners living in the country, according to the French Institute of Statistics (INSEE) [9]

 

The Murder of Samuel Paty has again intensified the stigmatization of immigrant communities. Paty was killed and beheaded by an Islamist terrorist. He had, in a class on freedom of expression, shown his students Charlie Hebdo's 2012 cartoons depicting the Islamic prophet Muhammad. One of the cartoons portrayed Muhammad naked with his genitals exposed. The cartoons having been protested by many Muslims in the past, Paty preemptively permitted his students to avert their eyes or leave the room while they were displayed. The perpetrator, Abdoullak, killed and beheaded Paty with a cleaver, and was shot and killed by the police minutes later.  Ten people have been charged with assisting the killer, including an imam, a parent of a student, and two students at Paty's school. They all have the same religious background and come from immigrant communities [6]. The attack on Patti was part of a public debate about how to integrate or integrate Islam into France's secular society. A public opinion survey, conducted by the Institute for the Republic of France (Ifop), found that 87 percent of respondents believed that France's secular society was under threat, while 79 per cent believed that Islam had declared war on France and the French republic. The survey found that 89 percent of those surveyed thought the threat from terrorism was high.

French Muslims in attendance at tribute for Paty [6]

 

Multiculturalism means that different ethnic groups can cooperate and talk with each other without sacrificing their special status. In terms of policy, society guarantees the interests of different ethnic groups with the authority of the state. After the second world war, large numbers of people from former colonies, most of them Muslim, migrated to Europe to make up for labor shortages. With the increase of immigration, immigrant communities dominated by Muslim communities appeared in Europe, forming religious beliefs and living habits different from the mainstream society. Therefore, most European countries have adopted multicultural policies, such as the United Kingdom, the Netherlands, Belgium and Sweden, which have adopted multi-lingual official languages and classified teaching policies. However, the rise of Muslim immigration has made social tensions more acute. In particular, In the last two decades, Islamist extremism has created a backlash against Muslim immigration in Europe. Since 2010, major European leaders have begun to declare multiculturalism a failure. The refugee crisis that began in 2015, with the increase of terrorist attacks, declared the complete failure of multiculturalism. As a result, Europe began to "turn to the right", which was marked by an increase in violent crimes and terrorist attacks against Muslims and immigrant groups. Through the analysis of the terrorist attackers and their targets, it can be seen that the Islamic extremist forces and the far-right forces are the main forces of the current terrorist attacks in Europe, and the two sides have staged a drama of "clash of civilizations" in Europe.

 

Especially against the backdrop of the economic crisis, anti-immigration trends are rising in Europe, and the theory of failure multiculturalism is constantly being mentioned. In the eyes of those who hold this view, American multiculturalism is the "melting pot" and European multiculturalism the "fence". By respecting and protecting the cultures of immigrants, Europeans bought their loyalty to our home countries. It is like encouraging immigrants to build fences and live on their own. When crisis strikes, however, some angry glances are directed at the world behind the fence.

 

The attacker of Hanau shootings is a typical example. 11 people were killed, 5 others were wounded in the shooting. All but the killer were of immigrant background, five of whom were Turkish. The shooting took place at two shisha bars frequented by Kurds in the city of Hanau. The shooter Tobias Rathjen was found dead in his home, killed his mother too. The perpetrator had suffered from schizophrenia and paranoia. The perpetrators are also socially isolated and addicted to online subcultures, particularly far-right and lone-wolf terrorism. The cause of the perpetrator's mental illness is unknown, he was not a marginalized member of society and held an MBA degree. What is clear is that mental illness and far-right ideology combined to contribute to the terrorist attack.

 

Another example is Halle synagogue shooting. The attack began at midnight on Yom Kippur, the Jewish day of atonement, at the synagogue in Halle. The attacker, Stephan Balliet, tried to broadcast his attack live on the Internet, but failed to blast the gates because the synagogue's security system had recently been upgraded. He later shot and killed a female bystander. After killing the woman, Balliet drove to a nearby kebab restaurant. He opened fire from the window, wounding a customer in the store. The perpetrator, Balliet, was a neo-Nazi and had no record of mental illness. In her live broadcast, Balliet denied the Holocaust and claimed that feminism led to fewer births, leading to mass immigration; He blamed the Jews for these problems. Police believe the perpetrators acted as imitations of a previous Christchurch Mosque shootings.

Bullet holes in the entrance door right in front of the synagogue [8]

 

Overall, terrorism and far-right extremism are the two major security problems facing Europe. Although this is due to a combination of social factors, early intervention and psychological support can play a positive role in preventing terrorism and extreme right-wing extremism. The government could improve oversight of the far right and, if necessary, impose mental health interventions for extreme involvers. For ethnic minorities and immigrants, there is a risk of discrimination in the use of health services, which causes them to deliberately not seek help from medical institutions when they face non-emergency injuries. Equality among communities is difficult to achieve to a certain extent, but community-based medical and health institutions can be a solution.

 

 

References

[1] Sarah Stark Casagrande, 2007, Perceived Discrimination and Adherence to Medical Care in a Racially Integrated Community

[2] Elizabeth Cantor-Graae, 2005, Schizophrenia and migration: a meta-analysis and review

[3] U. Kluge, 2020, Trauma-Zeitschrift für Psychotraumatologie und ihre Anwendung: Rassismus und psychische Gesundheit

[4] RD Putnam, E Pluribus Unum, 2007, Diversity and Community in the Twenty‐first Century, The 2006 Johan Skytte Prize Lecture

[5] BBC, eLondon bomber: Text in full, 1 September 2005. Retrieved 14 October 2010

[6] Murder of Samuel Paty,  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Samuel_Paty#Perpetrator

[7] Eurostat, 2020, Migrant integration statistics – labour market indicators

[8] Halle synagogue shooting, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halle_synagogue_shooting

[9] Arezki Benali, 2018, Les algériens sont la première communauté immigrée en Franc

What 9/11 Taught Us About Trauma

By Reba BroadfieldApril 28th, 2021in CJ 725

September 11, 2021 will mark 20 years since the terrorist attacks in New York City. Since then, we have learned how to communicate when phone and cable lines are down, and also what to do when evacuation routes are blocked as well as when roads to the nearest medical facilities are blocked. Not only did we learn important life saving lessons, but we also learned a lot about trauma and PTSD.

The powerful emotions that erupted from that day were not only felt in New York City or in surrounding states, but also across the United States and around the world. Two women who were in different parts of the city that day both experienced PTSD. Marcy Borders, who became known as Dust Lady, struggled for the decades following the attacks from depression as well as addictions to alcohol and crack cocaine. She is unfortunately one of many survivors who have struggled with mental illness and substance abuse since then. Esperanza Munoz witnessed the towers falling from a distance, but that doesn't change her experience. To this day, she still has flashbacks and nightmares as well as anxiety whenever she hears sirens or a plane flying overhead. She can't even step into New York City without panicking.

Many studies have been done on the affects of 9/11 and the first 9/11 trauma study was conducted on October 29, 2001. The team interviewed a huge range of survivors from the first responders, the recovery workers, those who survived the attacks themselves, and to those who lived in surrounding areas. They found that 96% of the survivors reported having experienced at least one symptom of PTSD 2 to 3 weeks after the tragedy. Of that 96%, a majority were still experiencing multiple symptoms 2 to 3 years afterwards. Another study on 9/11 focused on about 11,000 first responders and it was completed over a total of 8 years. They found that during the first year, at least 70% had actually never met the diagnoses criteria for PTSD but years later had many symptoms. Their study told them that the timelines of Post Traumatic Stress Disorder symptoms varied and hit people differently. They also found that these timelines are affected by the duration of the traumatic experience, the trauma-related medical experience, and also any prior psychiatric problems.

Not only have we learned in the almost two decades since then that PTSD symptoms rise up at different times for everyone and that trauma can be experienced by everyone, but psychologists themselves have learned new ways to react to major traumatic events like this one. Shortly after the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, psychologists themselves would ask those who were on Ground Zero or in the surrounding areas how they felt and if they were experiencing any symptoms. Years later, they have learned that not everyone is going to be traumatized and that everyone processes trauma differently. A new method that psychologists have come up with is called Psychological First Aid. Instead of asking the individual how they feel in the aftermath, the psychologist will offer the survivor services and give them information for the services. This not only allows flexibility, but it is also still reducing the distress caused by the event or events.

Unfortunately, that September day changed everything. Airport security is even tighter, rates of mental illness and PTSD have risen, and rates of substance abuse have risen. But at the same time, there have been positive changes that are allowing the country to prepare themselves for the next traumatic event or even to change the mental health field.

Resources

Cook, J. (2016, September 09). September 11th attacks: What we learned about trauma. Retrieved April 27, 2021, from https://time.com/4474573/911-september-11-trauma/

Pearson, C. (2011, November 09). 10 years after 9/11: What we now know about trauma. Retrieved April 27, 2021, from https://www.huffpost.com/entry/911-and-mental-health-a-n_n_951060

Researcher finds 9/11 attacks led to new understanding of mass trauma. (2011, August 31). Retrieved April 27, 2021, from https://news.columbia.edu/news/researcher-finds-911-attacks-led-new-understanding-mass-trauma

Surviving 9/11: Trauma and substance abuse. (n.d.). Retrieved April 27, 2021, from https://www.drugrehab.com/featured/9-11-trauma/