Teaching Resources: Fun Videos, Exercises, and Mock Supreme Court Cases
In Class Exercise on Examples of Bad Quantitative Inference
We use these examples in the Wire class. We have the students, in groups, try to figure out what might be problematic with them – selection bias, ignoring base rates, alternative explanations, selection on the DV etc. (ht to Jennifer Widner at Princeton for exposing me to something similar in grad school)
Notes — 1) The solution (in video form) to the item about the bomb dogs from the Ali G show is here. For another (perfect) example of “base rates” see the George Costanza clip about the Andrea Doria below. 2) Please send along other examples and I’ll add them to the exercise.
Fake Cases For Constitutional Law Exams
Two I’ve used recently. If interested, I have others but don’t want to post them all since I may reuse the ideas when I run out. Both are “ripped from the headlines.”
Commerce clause, interstate rest stops, and sugary drink bans
Free exercise, gender discrimination, and office hours
Fun Videos I (and others) Use to Illustrate and/or Introduce Concepts in Class
Many of these may be out of date. Apologies. I need to update this page!
Check back regularly for updates (and suggestions are very welcome)
Some of these have content some may find inappropriate for class so obviously watch first
Bureaucracy
- Bureaucratic discretion and “rule” making – The Wire: Colvin’s brown paper bag speech
- Bureaucracy, incentives, and measurement – The Wire “Juking the Stats”
- Regulatory capture (HT Shana Gadarian @SGadarian) – “Lemonade Wars“
Behavior and Opinion Related
- Motivated reasoning – Karl Rove and Ohio, Election Night 2012 (the Daily Show)
- Media as a business – Ali G with Sam Donaldson (2:45 in)
- Is it rational to vote? – Daily Show on first Afghan election
- Media debate culture (HT William Adler @williamadler78) Classic Saturday Night Live
- Low information undecided voters 2012 (HT William Adler @williamadler78) Saturday Night Live Sketch
- Low information undecided voters 2014 (HT Tali Mendelberg) Colbert on Ukraine
- Framing, low information, survey response etc. (HT William Adler @williamadler78) Jimmy Kimmel: Obamacare vs. Affordable Care Act
- Negative ads, (HT William Adler @williamadler78) Saturday Night Live Romney/Bain Ad
- Affective partisan polarization (HT Tali Mendelberg) The Daily Show
- Question wording: Jimmy Fallon on measuring opinion on marijuana legalization (starts 3:15 in or so)
Congress, Presidency, and other Institutions
- Pork and credit claiming – Robert Byrd “Big Daddy”
- Position taking – Daily Show, “How a Bill Becomes an Ad”
- The Electoral Connection — Daily Show (John Oliver) on gun control laws (HT Shana Gadarian)
- Position taking vs. substance – Daily Show on Senate on financial reform
- Public presidency / leadership – First pitches Good (Bush), Bad (Obama) , Ugly (Cincinatti Mayor)
- Federalism / Policy Experiments – (HT Bethany Albertson @AlbertsonB2) Frontline: The Pot Republic
- Local elections and campaigns – Documentary on Tom Menino’s run for city council in 1984
Law and Courts Related
- Judicial review and activism – The Daily Show no one is principled
- Supreme Court Legitimacy – Bush v. Gore 10th anniversary, CBS Sunday Morning
- Supreme Court Legitimacy – Bush v. Gore, Daily Show coverage from 2000
- Healthcare decision: tax vs. penalty – The Daily Show
- Healthcare decision: Roberts’s surprising decision and how the media blew it from the Daily Show
- Healthcare decision: CBS News, did Roberts change sides?
- Law vs. Politics (politics version) – The Daily Show on the Terry Schiavo case (pairs perfectly with discussion of Carter and Burke, Reason in Law, 5th edition chapter)
- Adversarial Legalism (Robert Kagan) – David Boies on the need to fight on behalf of AIG
- Legal compliance – the Atlanta highway 55MPH experiment
- Judicial appointments and politicization – attack ad on potential liberal nominee Diane Wood
- Judicial appointments and politicization – attack ad on Romney and Robert Bork
- Judicial appointments – Harriet Miers nomination from the Daily Show
- Judicial elections and TV Advertising (endless options on Youtube): A few highlights here, here, here
- Confirmation hearings and Senators position taking: Daily Show on Roberts
- Confirmation hearings and vacuousness: Daily Show on Kagan not answering questions
- Supreme Court Oral Arguments with Dog Justices: John Oliver
General Social Science and Miscellaneous
- Law, norms, disputes, and property rights – Snow Parking in Boston
- Norms – Curb Your Enthusiasm and how much caviar one can take
- Norms – Curb Your Enthusiasm: Taking a drink out of someone’s fridge without asking
- Norms – The Wire “Sunday Truce (no murders on church day” (Part 1) (potential spoilers, also language)
- Psychology and persuasion – (HT Bethany Albertson @AlbertsonB2) Frontline, The Persuaders
- Pure fun for Wire fans – Martin O’Malley’s / Carcetti’s campaign launch video
- The World is Stochastic -(HT Bethany Albertson @AlbertsonB2) The Onion: Jax Jaguars realize the world is random from coin toss
- Dangerous selective use of evidence and inference: Proof Cats are Better than Dogs
- Base rates: Seinfeld, George Costanza on the Andrea Doria. “How many do you lose on a normal cruise?